After making over 500 YouTube videos and growing a channel to 150,000 subscribers, I’ve noticed a pattern. Especially with brands.
They’re trying too hard to be perfect.
Polished lighting. Studio voiceovers. Scripted everything. Sleek, corporate-designed animations. It looks great. But it doesn’t work. Not on YouTube.
Because on YouTube, polish doesn’t build trust. In fact, it can break it.
If you’re wondering why your videos are getting low engagement, read on.
Why “Looking Professional” Can Hurt You
Most brands still treat YouTube like TV. Big intros. Fancy production. Corporate tone.
But YouTube isn’t TV. It’s not built for viewers who sit back and watch. It’s built for people who scroll, swipe and skip.
That means if your video feels like an ad, even a really good one, people will bounce.
It’s not about how it looks. It’s about how it feels.
Think Less “Studio,” More “FaceTime”
The best YouTubers talk like they’re in the room with you. It feels personal. Casual. Off-the-cuff.
But that doesn’t mean it’s sloppy. The best creators are obsessed with data. They know how long people watch. They know the exact second viewers drop off. They tweak thumbnails. Test hooks. Cut intros down to five seconds because that’s all they’ve got.
It feels effortless. But it’s built with intent.
Most brands miss that. They spend time on gear and scripts instead of studying audience behaviour. That’s a mistake. And it shows up in their numbers.
The Theatre Analogy: What Stage Are You Standing On?
There’s a great metaphor here from theatre.
For centuries, performances were staged behind a proscenium arch. A grand frame that separated the audience from the actors. It was formal. Controlled. Distant. The audience sat in the dark, quietly watching.
That’s how most brands still treat video. They’re on stage, presenting. Broadcasting. Showing.
But YouTube isn’t like that. YouTube is theatre-in-the-round. The audience is all around you. They’re part of the space. You’re not up on a platform performing at them. You’re among them.
If your content feels too staged, too polished, too rehearsed, people will feel the distance. They’ll check out.
Obsess Over the Story, Not the Setup
Forget the gear. Forget the polish. Obsess over the story.
Why should someone spend five minutes of their life watching this video when they could be watching a video about a skateboarding cat?
You need to earn that click. And then you need to keep earning it, second by second.
Ask yourself, brutally:
- What is this video really offering the viewer?
- Why does this matter to them?
- Am I saying something they haven’t heard before, or just adding noise?
If you can’t answer those questions honestly, don’t hit record yet.
Perfection Doesn’t Build Trust. People Do.
A slightly messy background. An unpolished take. A stumble over a word.
These aren’t flaws. They’re signals. They say, “This is real.” And that’s what works.
People don’t want to watch brands. They want to watch people. People they trust. People who sound like them. People who don’t feel like a sales pitch.
If your video feels too perfect, too produced, too controlled, it might be beautiful. But it probably won’t work.
The Fix: Be Useful. Be Real. Be Quick.
Here’s what brands should do instead:
- Ditch the long intros
- Talk to the camera like it’s a friend
- Cut the script. Keep the message
- Watch your own analytics. Obsess over the first 15 seconds
- Say something helpful. Say it fast. Then stop
That’s it.
Final Thought
If you’re a brand on YouTube, stop trying to look like you’re on TV.
You don’t need to perform. You need to connect.
Polish doesn’t build trust. Presence does.
And performance doesn’t matter if no one’s watching.
Start with honesty. Obsess over the story. Deliver value. Then earn the next second.
Because on YouTube, the way you show up is the message.
As Marshall McLuhan said, “The medium is the message.”
And if you’re still making content like it’s television, don’t be surprised when the audience treats it like an ad—and skips it.
Leave a Reply